Conflict Over Tradition  
     
 
Most organizations whether a church, business, club, or some other group have formal rules and a list of informal rules or expectations. Often the informal rules are more important than the formal ones. When conflicts occur, it is often over the unstated rules. The Jewish leaders of Jesus’ day had rules that God did not require. The Pharisees and Sadducees believed that God wrote the Torah, even though they ignored key parts. In addition to those writings, they created their own rules. A document called the Mishnah is a list of written rules that the Jews were supposed to follow. Jacob Neusner has published a new translation of the Mishnah. The book contains over 1,000 pages of rules. Almost every line on each page is a rule. It is an incredible number of rules that the Jewish leaders created. In addition, they had a list of oral rules. It must have been very difficult trying to follow the unwritten religious rules of Jesus’ day. This study explores the question, “How should we respond to the unwritten rules in our churches?”
Background. In our last study, Jesus attempted to help the crowd and the religious leaders understand that He had come down out of heaven, did the Father’s will, and was the Bread of Life - everything that they needed. Jesus explained that if anyone wanted to live forever, they had to come to Him, believe in Him, and include Him in their lives. As a result, many of Jesus’ so-called disciples struggled with His statements and deserted Him. The response of the religious leaders of Israel was worse. They wanted to kill Him. It was difficult for some to think of Jesus as a spiritual savior, and the religious leaders viewed him as competition. So Jesus was careful about where He walked. He remained in the north country - in Galilee.

After these things Jesus was walking in Galilee, for He was unwilling to walk in Judea because the Jews were seeking to kill Him. John 7:1 (NAS95S)

The Mishnah
 
Religious Leaders From Jerusalem. The religious leaders were greatly disturbed over Jesus. Even though they could not kill Him while He remained in Galilee, they tried to discredit Jesus before the people. So Mark 7:1 tells us that some Pharisees and scribes came up from Jerusalem to investigate Jesus.

The Pharisees and some of the scribes gathered around Him when they had come from Jerusalem, and had seen that some of His disciples were eating their bread with impure hands, that is, unwashed. Mark 7:1-2 (NAS95S)

Once the Pharisees and scribes arrived, they soon found fault with some action of Jesus’ disciples. We should not be surprised. That was their goal. When they arrived, they surrounded Jesus, and asked Him what they thought was a difficult question. They were disturbed that Jesus’ disciples had been eating bread without ceremonially washing their hands. The gospel of Mark adds this explanation about ceremonial washing,

For the Pharisees and all the Jews do not eat unless they carefully wash their hands, thus observing the traditions of the elders; and when they come from the market place, they do not eat unless they cleanse themselves; and there are many other things which they have received in order to observe, such as the washing of cups and pitchers and copper pots. Mark 7:3-4 (NAS95S)

The process of “carefully washing their hands” involved washing the hands before and after eating. The process required a person to take at least half an “egg-shell” of clear water and pour on both hands. The hands had to be free of gravel, dirt, mortar or any other contaminant. The hands had to lifted up so that the water would run down to the wrist in order to ensure that the whole hand was washed and the “dirty” water did not re-flow across the fingers. Then the hands were rubbed against one another. If the water did not flow down to the wrist, the Jewish rabbis said that the hands were not clean and the process had to be repeated. If the hands had gravel, dirt, mortar or other contaminants when the washing started, the process was repeated twice. However, the second time, the water had to flow from the wrist down over the fingers. There were other variations to the washing ritual, but we will not discuss them here.[1]
The rabbis adopted this ritual in response to the washing that God required Aaron and the priests to perform (Exodus 30:19; 40:12). They assumed that if it was good for the priest to do it, then it would be great for everyone to do it and to do it every day. The Jews tried to improve upon God’s laws. They even taught that the scriptures defiled the hands. Consequently, the hands needed to be washed after touching the scriptures. They burdened the people with their man made rules. Rules that God did not require. The religious leaders were trapped in their own system, having adopted a dishonoring system of supposedly religious righteousness.
The Elders' Tradition. When Jesus’ disciples did not perform the ritualistic washing, the Pharisees and the scribes became unhappy with them. Even though the Pharisees knew that the ceremonial washing was not required by the Mosaic Law, they did not care. The rules were now their rules. They wanted them obeyed. Listen,
 
Outline of Life and Heart of Jesus

 

References:
horizontal rule

1. Alfred Edersheim. The Life And Ties of Jesus The Messiah. Eerdmans Publishing Co., Grand Rapids, Michigan. 1973. Book 3, p. 11-12.

 
     
 
< Back
Next >
 
  Life & Heart of Jesus